How this answer was decided
Decision trace
26 Oct · decided in under 40 seconds. Nothing was released. Each step is signed or recorded.
- 0 s
Mykhailo Pronka sent the work
Recorded as bafkreib…m3nq.
- 20 s
asks.world verifier gathered the facts
6 AI reviews by openai/gpt-6-luna scored 99, 99, 98, 100, 99 and 98 out of 100. The facts were frozen before deciding. The verifier's record
- 34 s
IXO decision engine did not approve it
Of 10 rules, 8 met, 1 not met and 1 not reached.
- Handed over: met
- Long enough: met
- Report received: not met
- Approved by a person: not reached
- 6 judged by AI: met
- This ask wants a review report: hand in the structured report with every section it asks for, or attach the report as a PDF
Every rule in full
- Something was handed over: metmeasured
- Long enough for what the ask asked: metmeasured
- Every scenario in the brief has a step with what was done, what was expected, what was observed, and a result. Fail this only if a scenario in the brief has no step.: metAI review
- Every finding names the step it came from, what was observed against what was expected, and its impact on the user. Fail this only if a finding has no step, no observation or no impact.: metAI review
- Every blocker says how to reproduce it, or what is missing to reproduce it. Fail this only if a blocker says neither.: metAI review
- Every severity says why it is that severe, in terms of what the user could and could not do. Fail this only if a severity gives no reason.: metAI review
- The summary names the version tested, the devices or environment, and the dates. Fail this only if the version tested is missing.: metAI review
- The answer is a review report, either written out or attached as a PDF. It says what was checked, when, where and what was in scope, and the outcome; lists the steps taken, each with what was expected and what was seen, passed, failed, blocked, not tested or left out; lists the findings, each with its impact and a severity of blocker, major or minor with why, and every major finding says how to reproduce it (a blocker says how, or what is missing to reproduce it); gives recommendations, each with a priority and what would show it is done; and gives the review's limitations. It also has these sections: "First-time understanding", "Scenario coverage and assistance", "Prioritised UX improvements".: metAI review
- This ask wants a review report: hand in the structured report with every section it asks for, or attach the report as a PDF: not metmeasured
- A person approved the answer: not reachedmeasured
- 34 s
Signed by the decision engine
decision-engine.testnet.ixo.earth. The signature checks out against its published key. Check it
- 39 s
Recorded: not approved
Nothing was released.
Full engine trace pinned by hash 4c0b921d…